Light From Uncommon Stars
-Ryka Aoki
Rating 4.9/5 (the .1 is because the perspective will literally change within paragraphs and it gets annoying)
Warnings: Depictions of sexual assault, transphobia, death, etc.
Recommended for you if
- You are trans, especially a trans-fem.
- You enjoy found family (let's be real, if you're reading my site, you do), give it a read.
- You want a contemporary story with sci-fi and supernatural elements colliding.
- You want to cry (mostly in the last 15-20% of the novel but it's ugly cry).
Not recommended for you if
- You are seeking a romance novel (it's a slow-burn and not the focus of the novel)
- You want fap material, there is none.
- You don't like contemporary settings (it's modern day, cell phones, etc).
Spoiler-free review
Forgive me for names, there's not a proper list that I can find and I listened to it. I'm not 100% on spellings.
I went into this because I needed an audiobook to listen to, but didn't want to take a third trip through the cosmere, and I wanted something decidedly queer and maybe a little spicy. So I hit up the pride library and filtered down to adult rating, fantasy, with trans-fem representation.
Depressingly short list honestly (and I may well do some writing because of that. "be the change you want to see in the world" and all that). But it was highly rated and decent length for my purposes (something for a road trip while I go out on a photography run), so I spent a credit on Libro.FM and gave it a go.
I went in with no more knowledge than the city it was primarily set in and the above listed tags from the pride library. I did not expect to burn through an almost 14 hour audiobook in less than 24 hours. I did not expect to have to pause the book at one point and find a safe place to pull over before I could resume because I would spend a solid 40 minutes ugly crying on the side of the road. I did not expect to get the inspiration to pick up music again.
Suffice to say, I was ill prepared for what this novel would do to me. It rides this line of fantastical, but with (what I believe to be) realistic reactions to it. People seeing evidence of clearly alien technology and just running with it. People having casual conversations with a demon and being unnerved, but not freaked out beyond their own normal life.
I'm so used to a character meeting something magical/spiritual/alien and having that moment define their personality going forward. I never expected to see a character take the reveal of an alien revealing themself openly as if it was just something interesting. You're telling me someone who has had dealing with demons isn't going to just live in denial about aliens? That a character can take past experience with the supernatual and extrapolate that into a reasonable understanding that maybe there's more to existence than they previously expected?
How many times have you seen a character awaken to the abilty to lift tons of stone outright deny that someone else can do something magical?
This is an aspect of the novel that I think is subtly defining. The characters are intelligent, they have lived lives, they react like people rather than characters. And while this isn't what the novel is about, it absolutely is something that makes the conflict so much more engaging. When something happens, it's both easier to guess what will happen, and infinitely harder. Because the characters will not react like you would expect in fiction, in a story, but they react like human beings.
And what that means is you can connect with these characters on a more than superficial level. When a character feels hurt, you feel it. They aren't hurt because they're a character on a page, they're hurt because anyone would be. They're all, every single main character, complete people with trauma, responses, and personalities.
I've gotten this far without really saying anything about the story, so let me give a quick summary (Skip the next paragraph if you want a fully zero spoiler review, but at that point just read the damn book).
Semi-spoiler
Shizuka Satomi is a naturally gifted musician that has made a deal with hell to deliver souls in exhange for her own. Katrina Nguyen is a young trans girl that has fled an abusive home into a situation that is arguably worse, with some money made through sex work, and a cheap violin she bought off ebay, and pretty much nothing else. Satomi has already made good on all but 1 of the souls she promised and after nearly a decade of searching, she may have found the final one in Katrina.
End semi-spoiler
With that out of the way, I can't help but recommend this novel wholeheartedly.
Spoilers below for those that have read
Seriously, stop reading if you haven't read it
Spoilers
Spoilers
Spoliers
There's so many moments in this novel that just landed with me like a grenade.
When Shirley tried to tell Katrina that her life was in danger, and Katrina's reaction was just "I know, I expect I won't survive, I never did" basically, it just hit me because we've all been there to an extent (or at least I assume we all have? I don't know anymore). That point where you have just been beaten down over and over and over by life and people and you start looking at any and all positive things just waiting for the collapse. For the other shoe to drop. For the inevitable taint to creep in. All good things come with a price, all good people have a reason, all the kindness shown to you eventually comes with a price tag.
And sometimes you see it, you know it, and you still let yourself indulge. Because at a certain point life is going to continue fucking you sans-lube regardless, so you can at least have something positive out of it. It's a defense mechanism that can come from abuse. "I know this person is going to hurt me, I just don't know when, but until then they give me warmth"
Katrina's final performance was soul wrenching for me. That's when I had to pull over. I paused when the demon was talking to her because I knew it was about to hit that climax. I knew I wasn't going to handle the next bit well, when she gives herself up to save Shizuka. So I paused it, pulled over, and hit play. I didn't expect nearly 40 minutes of absolute headache inducing ugly cry. Katrina blind to her own beauty after a lifetime of dysphoria, ready to see herself turned into an object once again, not happily but readily giving herself over for the woman that gave her a brief glimpse at love and acceptance. Staring down not an unknown hell, but a return to the life that almost had her give her own up and accepting it willingly.
Then it was followed by the rug pull from Shizuka, showing that the beauty the crowd saw was real, it was Katrina, and she is deserving of love. It just cracked me wide open.
This novel is so good. It's so high on my list.



